Outcomes at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in adolescents and young adults in the USA: a follow-up surveillance study
Data on medium-term outcomes in indivduals with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination are scarce. We aimed to assess clinical outcomes and quality of life at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in adolescents and young adults.
Methods
In this follow-up surveillance study, we conducted surveys in US individuals aged 12–29 years with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination, for whom a report had been filed to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System between Jan 12 and Nov 5, 2021. A two-component survey was administered, one component to patients (or parents or guardians) and one component to health-care providers, to assess patient outcomes at least 90 days since myocarditis onset. Data collected were recovery status, cardiac testing, and functional status, and EuroQol health-related quality-of-life measures (dichotomised as no problems or any problems), and a weighted quality-of-life measure, ranging from 0 to 1 (full health). The EuroQol results were compared with published results in US populations (aged 18–24 years) from before and early on in the COVID-19 pandemic.
Findings
Between Aug 24, 2021, and Jan 12, 2022, we collected data for 519 (62%) of 836 eligible patients who were at least 90 days post-myocarditis onset: 126 patients via patient survey only, 162 patients via health-care provider survey only, and 231 patients via both surveys. Median patient age was 17 years (IQR 15–22); 457 (88%) patients were male and 61 (12%) were female. 320 (81%) of 393 patients with a health-care provider assessment were considered recovered from myocarditis by their health-care provider, although at the last health-care provider follow-up, 104 (26%) of 393 patients were prescribed daily medication related to myocarditis. Of 249 individuals who completed the quality-of-life portion of the patient survey, four (2%) reported problems with self-care, 13 (5%) with mobility, 49 (20%) with performing usual activities, 74 (30%) with pain, and 114 (46%) with depression. Mean weighted quality-of-life measure (0·91 [SD 0·13]) was similar to a pre-pandemic US population value (0·92 [0·13]) and significantly higher than an early pandemic US population value (0·75 [0·28]; p<0·0001). Most patients had improvements in cardiac diagnostic marker and testing data at follow-up, including normal or back-to-baseline troponin concentrations (181 [91%] of 200 patients with available data), echocardiograms (262 [94%] of 279 patients), electrocardiograms (240 [77%] of 311 patients), exercise stress testing (94 [90%] of 104 patients), and ambulatory rhythm monitoring (86 [90%] of 96 patients). An abnormality was noted among 81 (54%) of 151 patients with follow-up cardiac MRI; however, evidence of myocarditis suggested by the presence of both late gadolinium enhancement and oedema on cardiac MRI was uncommon (20 [13%] of 151 patients). At follow-up, most patients were cleared for all physical activity (268 [68%] of 393 patients).
Interpretation
After at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination, most individuals in our cohort were considered recovered by health-care providers, and quality of life measures were comparable to those in pre-pandemic and early pandemic populations of a similar age. These findings might not be generalisable given the small sample size and further follow-up is needed for the subset of patients with atypical test results or not considered recovered.
Funding
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Introduction
Evidence from the USA and multiple international vaccine safety monitoring systems support a small but increased risk of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination.
1
WHO COVID-19 subcommittee of the World Health Organization Global Advisory Committee on Vaccine Safety: updated guidance regarding myocarditis and pericarditis reported with COVID-19 mRNA vaccines.
In 2021, data from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) indicated that in US individuals aged 12 years or older, approximately 4·8 cases of myocarditis per million doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines administered were reported, with the highest reporting rates in those aged 12–29 years.
2
Gargano JW
Wallace M
Hadler SC
et al.
Use of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine after reports of myocarditis among vaccine recipients: update from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices—United States, June, 2021.
Despite the higher than expected occurrence of myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination, the benefits of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines have been shown to outweigh the risk of myocarditis.
2
Gargano JW
Wallace M
Hadler SC
et al.
Use of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine after reports of myocarditis among vaccine recipients: update from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices—United States, June, 2021.
,
3
Block JP
Boehmer TK
Forrest CB
et al.
Cardiac complications after SARS-CoV-2 infection and mRNA COVID-19 vaccination—PCORnet, United States, January, 2021–January, 2022.
Research in context
Evidence before this study
In December, 2020, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued emergency use authorisations (EUAs) for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 (BNT162b2) vaccine and the Moderna COVID-19 (mRNA-1273) vaccine. In May, 2021, FDA expanded the EUA for the BNT162b2 vaccine to include adolescents aged 12–15 years. By July, 2022, more than 200 million people in the USA had received two doses of a COVID-19 mRNA vaccine and more than 1500 cases of myocarditis with onset after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination were reported to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS). We searched PubMed for articles published up to April 30, 2022, using the keywords “mRNA vaccine” and “myocarditis”, without any language restrictions. Systematic reviews published in 2022 included more than 5299 individuals with myocarditis after mRNA vaccination and suggested the risk was highest in adolescents and young males after a second vaccine dose. Findings from these systematic reviews suggest that most cases of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination have resolution of symptoms at or soon after discharge from a short hospital stay. However, data on medium-term prognoses for adolescents and young adults diagnosed with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination are scarce.
Added value of this study
To our knowledge, this is the largest evaluation of outcomes among patients diagnosed with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination, with follow-up at least 90 days since onset. We collected data from both patients (or their parents or guardians) and health-care providers, and evaluated a comprehensive range of outcomes, including follow-up cardiac biomarkers, cardiac magnetic resonance imaging, echocardiograms, troponin levels, and electrocardiograms. We found that 320 (81%) of 393 patients with a health-care provider assessment were considered recovered from myocarditis, and quality of life measures were similar to pre-pandemic or early pandemic measurements. No single diagnostic test or clinical feature appeared to be associated with recovered status.
Implications of all the available evidence
Myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination is rare, but potentially serious. To better understand possible longer term sequalae of myocarditis, continued follow-up is important, particularly for the patients not recovered by at least 90 days since symptom onset. Vaccination remains the most effective way of preventing morbidity and mortality from COVID-19.
Cardiac assessment of patients diagnosed with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination often shows increased cardiac biomarkers (eg, troponin concentrations) and atypical cardiac imaging (eg, echocardiograms), which are similar findings to those shown for viral or acute myocarditis.,
5
Oster ME
Shay DK
Su JR
et al.
Myocarditis cases reported after mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccination in the US from December, 2020 to August, 2021.
Viral myocarditis unrelated to mRNA COVID-19 vaccination can lead to heart failure, cardiac transplantation, or death.
6
Ghelani SJ
Spaeder MC
Pastor W
Spurney CF
Klugman D
Demographics, trends, and outcomes in pediatric acute myocarditis in the United States, 2006 to 2011.
Conversely, case descriptions suggest that clinical outcomes following a diagnosis of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination are more favourable than those associated with viral myocarditis, with resolution of symptoms often described at or soon after discharge from a short hospital stay for myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination.
5
Oster ME
Shay DK
Su JR
et al.
Myocarditis cases reported after mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccination in the US from December, 2020 to August, 2021.
,
7
Sinagra G
Anzini M
Pereira NL
et al.
Myocarditis in clinical practice.
,
8
Witberg G
Barda N
Hoss S
et al.
Myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination in a large health care organization.
,
9
Truong DT
Dionne A
Muniz JC
et al.
Clinically suspected myocarditis temporally related to COVID-19 vaccination in adolescents and young adults: suspected myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination.
However, data on follow-up prognoses for adolescents and young adults diagnosed with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination are scarce.
10
Amir G
Rotstein A
Razon Y
et al.
CMR imaging 6 months after myocarditis associated with the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine.
,
11
Fronza M
Thavendiranathan P
Karur GR
et al.
Cardiac MRI and clinical follow-up in COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis.
,
12
Jain SS
Steele JM
Fonseca B
et al.
COVID-19 vaccination-associated myocarditis in adolescents.
To conduct surveillance, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) developed a working myocarditis case definition with a team of subspecialists that has been used in several studies.
2
Gargano JW
Wallace M
Hadler SC
et al.
Use of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine after reports of myocarditis among vaccine recipients: update from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices—United States, June, 2021.
,
5
Oster ME
Shay DK
Su JR
et al.
Myocarditis cases reported after mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccination in the US from December, 2020 to August, 2021.
,
9
Truong DT
Dionne A
Muniz JC
et al.
Clinically suspected myocarditis temporally related to COVID-19 vaccination in adolescents and young adults: suspected myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination.
,
13
Goddard K
Lewis N
Fireman B
et al.
Risk of myocarditis and pericarditis following BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 COVID-19 vaccination.
In August, 2021, the CDC began follow-up of myocarditis cases to describe medium-term outcomes in the age group with the highest risk of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination diagnosis (ie, individuals aged 12–29 years). We report findings of clinical outcomes and quality of life at least 90 days since the onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in adolescents and young adults aged 12–29 years.
Results
Between Jan 12 and Nov 5, 2021, 989 cases of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in patients aged 12–29 years were reported to VAERS and met the CDC’s case definition for myocarditis. Of these, 836 (85%) patients were at least 90 days post-myocarditis onset (figure 1). Of the 836 patients, 204 (24%) patients had no telephone number available for contact and 257 (31%) patients were unreachable. Of the remaining 375 patients, 357 (95%) patients consented to the survey and 18 (5%) patients declined. Between Aug 24, 2021, and Jan 12, 2022, we contacted and collected data for 519 (62%) of the 836 eligible patients: 126 patients via patient survey only, 162 patients via health-care provider survey only, and 231 patients via both the patient and health-care provider survey (figure 1). Median interval from myocarditis onset to survey completion was 143 days (IQR 131–162) for patients and 191 days (170–216) for health-care providers. We found no significant differences in VAERS reporter type (health-care provider or patient), geographical census region, age, sex, initial echocardiogram findings, or race or ethnicity in patients surveyed compared with patients who were not surveyed (appendix 1 p 8). In a subset of patients with abnormal echocardiograms, the abnormality identified was a left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) of less than 50%. Of the 100 survey respondents with LVEF values recorded at their initial diagnosis, 33 (33%) had LVEF values less than 50%, which was not statistically different from the results in non-respondents (27 [42%] of 65 non-respondents; χ2=1·24, p=0·265).
Figure 1Survey participation of patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination reported to VAERS at least 90 days since symptom onset
Show full caption
CDC=US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. VAERS=Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System.
For 393 (47%) of 836 patients, health-care providers were contacted; 241 (61%) of 393 were cardiologists. At the time of the survey, health-care providers considered 320 (81%) of 393 patients to be recovered: 261 (66%) patients were considered fully recovered and 59 (15%) patients were considered to be probably recovered but awaiting further information. An additional 61 (16%) patients had improved and four patients had the same cardiac status as at the initial myocarditis diagnosis; these 65 patients were categorised as not fully recovered (figure 1). The cumulative proportion of patients considered recovered in the time (weeks) since the last health-care provider encounter is shown in appendix 1 (p 15). The median time from myocarditis symptom onset to the last health-care provider encounter for patients who were considered probably fully recovered or fully recovered was 92 days (IQR 43–133), and for patients who were considered fully recovered the median time was 84 days (36–135).
Most patients were male (457 [88%] of 519 patients) and White non-Hispanic (274 [53%]), and the median age of all patients was 17 years (IQR 15–22; table 1). 98 (19%) of 519 patients were Hispanic of any race. There was no notable difference between recovered individuals compared with individuals who were not recovered across any ethnic or racial groups. Overall, patients considered to be recovered and not recovered from myocarditis were similar with respect to age (median age 17 years [IQR 15–21] for patients considered recovered vs 17 years [15–21] for those considered not recovered) and sex (290 [91%] male individuals who were considered recovered vs 56 [86%] of male individuals who were considered not to be recovered, and 30 [9%] female individuals who were considered recovered vs 9 [14%] of female individuals who were not considered recovered). The median time from illness onset to health-care provider interview for the 320 (81%) of 393 individuals who were considered recovered was 189 days (IQR 167–214), and for the 61 (16%) of 393 patients who were considered improved but not fully recovered the median time was 195 days (179–195).
Table 1Demographic characteristics and symptoms of patients by provider-reported recovery status from myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination
Data are n (%) unless specified otherwise. Data are based on the completion of 357 patient surveys, 393 provider surveys, and 231 linked surveys, resulting in 519 patients for which data were collected. Health-care provider determination of patient myocarditis recovery was provided for 393 patients, of whom 320 were considered fully or probably fully recovered and 65 were not considered recovered (and eight patients had an undetermined recovery status; figure 1). Based on the last patient encounter, health-care providers reported that 62 (16%) of 393 patients had at least one symptom that might occur with myocarditis.
In the 2 weeks before the survey date, 178 (50%) of 357 patients reported having at least one symptom that might occur with myocarditis (chest pain or discomfort, fatigue, shortness of breath, or palpitations). Patients who were not considered recovered from myocarditis more frequently reported fatigue than did patients who were considered recovered (12 [43%] vs 40 [21%]; p=0·018; table 1). By contrast, based on the last patient encounter, health-care providers reported that 62 (16%) of 393 patients at least one symptom that might occur with myocarditis (table 1).
Of 357 patients surveyed, 267 (75%) were enrolled in school or in paid employment; 43 (16%) of whom reported missing school or workdays in the 2 weeks before the survey date. Of those 43 patients, 15 (35%) believed it was associated with myocarditis.
Of 357 patients surveyed, 249 (71%) consented to completing both the EQ-5D-5L and EQ-VAS components of the patient survey. Of 249 patients, four (2%) reported problems with self-care, 13 (5%) with mobility, 49 (21%) with performing usual activities, 74 (30%) with pain, and 114 (46%) with anxiousness or depression (figure 2A). Overall, patients reported having good health, reflected by the high median weighted index score (0·94; IQR 0·88–1·00) and median overall health status (EQ-VAS) score (90; 80–95; figure 2B, C).
Figure 2Self-assessment of health-related quality of life among patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination
Show full caption
(A) Bar plot of health-related quality of life among patients. Patients were administered the EuroQol 5-dimension 5-severity level questionnaire; for analysis, the five health-related dimensions were dichotomised into the frequency of problems (severity levels 2–5) and no problems (level 1). (B) Violin plot of weighted quality of life measure (using value weights in appendix 1 p 7) converted from each patient health profile from (A) to an index score between 1 (perfect health) and 0 (equivalent to death). (C) Violin plot of patient self-assessed overall health on a scale from 0 to 100 (with 100 representing best possible health and 0 representing the worst possible health). The denominator for the EuroQol questionnaire was 249 respondents. In the violin plots (B, C), the limits of the boxes denote IQR and the horizontal line denotes median values. Whisker endpoints are equal to the maximum and minimum values below or above the median plus or minus 1·5 times the IQR. The width of the outer shape around the box plots indicates the probability density of values or responses with a given result.
The mean EQ-5D-5L weighted utility score in our group (0·91 [SD 0·13]) was significantly higher than that for US respondents aged 18–24 years who completed a EQ-5D-5L questionnaire during the pandemic, as reported by Hay and colleagues
22
Hay JW
Gong CL
Jiao X
et al.
A US population health survey on the impact of COVID-19 using the EQ-5D-5L.
(0·75 [0·28]; p
23
Jiang R
Janssen MFB
Pickard AS
US population norms for the EQ-5D-5L and comparison of norms from face-to-face and online samples.
The weighted score from our survey was not significantly different to that obtained in the face-to-face surveys (0·92 [0·13]), but our score was significantly higher than that from the online surveys (0·84 [0·18]; p
Most patients were admitted to hospital after an initial diagnosis of myocarditis (484 [93%] of 519 patients). Of these 484 patients, 393 (81%) patients had information on level of care, according to the health-care provider surveys; 99 (25%) of these 393 patients were treated in an intensive care unit and one (table 2). To our knowledge, no deaths occurred during follow-up among the patients eligible for the survey. Six (2%) of 357 patients who self-reported re-admission to hospital had a hospital admission because of an adverse event after myocarditis treatment (n=3; adverse reactions to intravenous immune globulin) or had any cardiac abnormality identified (n=3; appendix 1 p 6); all patients were discharged within 1 week.
Table 2Level of care, testing, and treatment by recovery status among patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination
Data are n (%) unless otherwise specified. Data are based on the completion of 393 health-care provider surveys. Health-care provider determination of patient myocarditis recovery was provided for 393 patients, of whom 320 were considered fully or probably fully recovered, 65 were not considered recovered, and the health-care provider was unsure of the recovery status in eight patients, as shown in figure 1. Follow-up cardiac testing was performed, although the result of the test was not available for troponin concentration in three patients, echocardiogram in five patients, cardiac MRI in seven patients, exercise stress testing in five patients, and ambulatory rhythm monitoring in nine patients.
At follow-up, fewer patients had restrictions on physical activity than at initial diagnosis, and 34 (52%) of 65 individuals with restrictions on physical activity at the time of follow-up who were not considered recovered were cleared for all physical activity; 31 (48%) individuals still had restrictions (table 2). Median interval from myocarditis onset to approval for all physical activity was 98 days (IQR 57–134; table 2).
104 (26%) of 393 patients were prescribed daily medications related to myocarditis at the last health-care provider encounter (table 2). Patients who were not considered recovered from myocarditis were more frequently prescribed daily medication than were patients who were considered to be recovered. The most prescribed medications, as of the last health-care provider follow-up, were colchicine, β-blockers, and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (table 2).
At follow-up, most patients had improvements in diagnostic marker and imaging data, including normal or back-to-baseline troponin concentrations, echocardiograms, exercise stress testing, ambulatory rhythm monitoring, and electrocardiograms (figure 3). In the ten patients with abnormal ambulatory rhythm monitoring results, we found eight (80%) had atrial, supraventricular, or ventricular arrhythmia, three (30%) had a conduction delay or block, and five (50%) had frequent atrial or ventricular ectopy. Of these 10 patients, three (30%) had evidence of late gadolinium enhancement on follow-up cardiac MRI; of the three with evidence of late gadolinium enhancement, two (67%) had evidence of an atrial, supraventricular, or ventricular arrhythmia. Among the 151 patients who had cardiac MRIs during outpatient follow-up, 81 (54%) patients had one or more abnormalities. Abnormal cardiac MRI findings included the presence of late gadolinium enhancement (71 [47%] patients), inflammation or oedema (22 [15%] patients), or wall motion abnormalities (six [4%] patients; figure 3, appendix 1 p 9). Evidence of ongoing myocarditis, defined by both late gadolinium enhancement and oedema using modified Lake Louise criteria,
25
Ferreira VM
Schulz-Menger J
Holmvang G
et al.
Cardiovascular magnetic resonance in nonischemic myocardial inflammation: expert recommendations.
was uncommon (20 [13%] of 151 patients; appendix 1 p 9). Median interval from symptom onset to evidence of ongoing myocarditis was 26 days (IQR, 9–94) and from symptom onset to evidence of late gadolinium enhancement was 109 days (58–163; appendix 1 p 10). Of the 67 patients with late gadolinium enhancement or evidence of ongoing myocarditis, additional follow-up testing indicated abnormal echocardiograms in five (7%) patients, abnormal troponin concentrations in five (7%) patients, and abnormal electrocardiograms in 14 (21%) patients (appendix 1 p 13).
Figure 3Follow-up functional status, biomarker testing, and cardiac imaging in patients at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination
Show full caption
Cardiac biomarker testing or imaging findings are from the health-care provider surveys completed for 393 patients. Not all patients received diagnostic testing or imaging and the denominator for each follow-up test is equal to the sum of the normal and abnormal findings; the type of abnormalities identified are not mutually exclusive.
In the subset of patients with abnormal findings at the time of myocarditis diagnosis, abnormal diagnostic markers or abnormal imaging were also observed at follow-up in seven (12%) of 60 with initial abnormal echocardiograms, 19 (5%) of 387 with initial elevated troponin levels, and 47 (32%) of 146 with initial abnormal cardiac MRIs (figure 4). There was substantial heterogeneity in cardiac biomarkers, imaging, and patient functional status between patients considered recovered or not recovered from myocarditis (appendix 1 p 16). All cardiac test results (ie, echocardiogram, electrocardiogram, cardiac MRI, and troponin) were available for follow-up review in only 199 (62%) of 320 patients considered recovered, 44 (68%) of 65 considered not recovered, and three (38%) of eight with an unknown recovery status.
Figure 4Changes in cardiac biomarker and imaging from the initial encounter and the health-care provider follow-up
Show full caption
Testing, including echocardiograms, cardiac MRIs, and troponin concentrations, performed at the time of initial myocarditis diagnosis and at follow-up are not necessarily matched because each patient had testing (or not) at the discretion of the treating health-care providers.
Discussion
We ascertained outcomes at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis among 519 patients aged 12–29 years who received an mRNA COVID-19 vaccination and met the CDC case definition for myocarditis. Most (81%) patients for whom a follow-up health-care provider survey was completed were considered recovered from myocarditis, and most self-reported overall good health on the EQ-5D-5L. Readmissions to hospital were uncommon, and no deaths were identified during the follow-up period. Myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination is rare yet potentially serious, and although most patients were considered recovered by health-care providers at least 90 days since onset, nearly half of patients continued to self-report symptoms, including chest pain, and a quarter were prescribed daily cardiac medications. These findings suggest that continued follow-up and assessment of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination is needed to more fully understand recovery after vaccine-associated myocarditis.
From a clinical standpoint, our findings suggest that myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination could have a more favourable prognosis than myocarditis after viral infection, based on data available from the pre-COVID-19 period. In a published study of outcomes in children within 90 days of viral or acute myocarditis onset in the USA, 119 (23%) of 514 individuals required extracorporeal membrane oxygenation or a ventricular-assisted device and 58 (11%) of 514 individuals required cardiac transplant or died.
6
Ghelani SJ
Spaeder MC
Pastor W
Spurney CF
Klugman D
Demographics, trends, and outcomes in pediatric acute myocarditis in the United States, 2006 to 2011.
In a recent nationwide study in Denmark of adults, 90-day all-cause mortality among those with acute myocarditis was 4·9%.
26
Kragholm KH
Lindgren FL
Zaremba T
et al.
Mortality and ventricular arrhythmia after acute myocarditis: a nationwide registry-based follow-up study.
A longer term follow-up study of acute myocarditis among older adults (median age 34 years [IQR 24–42]) in Italy observed cardiac mortality or heart transplant rates at 1 year and 5 years of 3·0% and 4·1%, respectively, although complicated cases had rates of adverse cardiac outcomes that were several times higher.
27
Ammirati E
Cipriani M
Moro C
et al.
Clinical presentation and outcome in a contemporary cohort of patients with acute myocarditis: multicenter Lombardy registry.
In contrast with these studies, we found that only four (1%) patients had the same cardiac status as at the initial myocarditis diagnosis (ie, did not improve but did not worsen), whereas more than 95% (381 of 393 patients) showed improvement or recovery. Consistent with our findings, a recent report comparing classic myocarditis to COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in individuals aged younger than 21 years observed similar clinical presentations and found COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis had better outcomes and a more rapid cardiac recovery.
28
Patel T
Kelleman M
West Z
et al.
Comparison of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children-related myocarditis, classic viral myocarditis, and COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in children.
Published data for health-related quality of life in the USA among individuals aged 18–24 years, before the COVID-19 pandemic, showed that 45 (42%) of 107 individuals reported anxiety or depression and 35 (33%) of 107 individuals reported pain or discomfort.
23
Jiang R
Janssen MFB
Pickard AS
US population norms for the EQ-5D-5L and comparison of norms from face-to-face and online samples.
More recent quality of life measure data from Hay and colleagues
22
Hay JW
Gong CL
Jiao X
et al.
A US population health survey on the impact of COVID-19 using the EQ-5D-5L.
among US respondents during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic showed that 1653 (60·2%) of 2746 individuals reported anxiety or depression.
22
Hay JW
Gong CL
Jiao X
et al.
A US population health survey on the impact of COVID-19 using the EQ-5D-5L.
Consistent with these observations, we found that patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination reported similar or better quality of life measures than the general US population, with fewer patients with myocarditis reporting anxiety or depression than did individuals during the pandemic (46% [114/249] vs 60·2% [1653/2746]). However, absence of age-specific data in the previous analyses
22
Hay JW
Gong CL
Jiao X
et al.
A US population health survey on the impact of COVID-19 using the EQ-5D-5L.
,
23
Jiang R
Janssen MFB
Pickard AS
US population norms for the EQ-5D-5L and comparison of norms from face-to-face and online samples.
precluded any further statistical comparisons in this study.
Despite clinical improvements and normalisation of most diagnostic test results, as noted by health-care providers, half of patients (178/357) surveyed continued to report at least one symptom potentially associated with myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination. One possible explanation for the persistence of symptoms is that approximately 50% of patients reported depression or anxiety, conditions that can manifest as symptoms associated with myocarditis, such as chest pain or palpitations.
29
Lipsitz JD
Masia-Warner C
Apfel H
et al.
Anxiety and depressive symptoms and anxiety sensitivity in youngsters with noncardiac chest pain and benign heart murmurs.
The meaning of the cardiac MRI findings among the subset of patients who received cardiac imaging is unclear. Evidence of ongoing myocarditis on follow-up cardiac MRIs based on modified Lake Louise criteria
25
Ferreira VM
Schulz-Menger J
Holmvang G
et al.
Cardiovascular magnetic resonance in nonischemic myocardial inflammation: expert recommendations.
was uncommon. However, consistent with the few published case series of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination, we observed that nearly half of patients (71/151) with follow-up cardiac MRIs had residual late gadolinium enhancement, suggestive of myocardial scarring.
10
Amir G
Rotstein A
Razon Y
et al.
CMR imaging 6 months after myocarditis associated with the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine.
,
11
Fronza M
Thavendiranathan P
Karur GR
et al.
Cardiac MRI and clinical follow-up in COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis.
,
12
Jain SS
Steele JM
Fonseca B
et al.
COVID-19 vaccination-associated myocarditis in adolescents.
,
25
Ferreira VM
Schulz-Menger J
Holmvang G
et al.
Cardiovascular magnetic resonance in nonischemic myocardial inflammation: expert recommendations.
We did not note the degree of late gadolinium enhancement identified during follow-up, but a recent study that assessed serial cardiac MRIs in patients younger than 19 years with myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination and persistent late gadolinium enhancement showed improvement over time.
30
Hadley SM
Prakash A
Baker AL
et al.
Follow-up cardiac magnetic resonance in children with vaccine-associated myocarditis.
In a small subset of patients, initial cardiac imaging at diagnosis was normal but follow-up imaging was abnormal. It is possible that clinical findings in these patients continued to evolve after diagnosis. Another possibility is that the initial and follow-up imaging results were evaluated by different health-care providers, who had varying interpretations.
In previous studies during the pre-COVID era, cardiac scarring related to myocarditis on follow-up MRI was not uncommon, yet its clinical significance has remained controversial.
10
Amir G
Rotstein A
Razon Y
et al.
CMR imaging 6 months after myocarditis associated with the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine.
,
31
Grün S
Schumm J
Greulich S
et al.
Long-term follow-up of biopsy-proven viral myocarditis: predictors of mortality and incomplete recovery.
,
32
Law YM
Lal AK
Chen S
et al.
Diagnosis and management of myocarditis in children: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association.
,
33
Dubey S
Agarwal A
Nguyen S
Adebo D
Persistence of late gadolinium enhancement on follow-up CMR imaging in children with acute myocarditis.
Although late gadolinium enhancement during the acute episode of myocarditis has been shown in children and adults to be a possible indication of future adverse cardiac events, including arrythmias, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, transplantation, and death,
31
Grün S
Schumm J
Greulich S
et al.
Long-term follow-up of biopsy-proven viral myocarditis: predictors of mortality and incomplete recovery.
,
34
Aquaro GD
Perfetti M
Camastra G
et al.
Cardiac Magnetic Resonance Working Group of the Italian Society of Cardiology. Cardiac MR with late gadolinium enhancement in acute myocarditis with preserved systolic function: ITAMY study.
,
35
Lota AS
Tsao A
Owen R
et al.
Prognostic significance of nonischemic myocardial fibrosis in patients with normal LV volumes and ejection-fraction.
,
36
Gräni C
Eichhorn C
Bière L
et al.
Prognostic value of cardiac magnetic resonance tissue characterization in risk stratifying patients with suspected myocarditis.
the importance of late gadolinium enhancement noted on follow-up cardiac MRIs in patients with viral myocarditis is unclear.
31
Grün S
Schumm J
Greulich S
et al.
Long-term follow-up of biopsy-proven viral myocarditis: predictors of mortality and incomplete recovery.
Indeed, guidelines regarding clearance of athletes for competitive sports after myocarditis acknowledge the unclear role of cardiac MRI in the follow-up of such patients.
37
Maron BJ
Udelson JE
Bonow RO
et al.
Eligibility and disqualification recommendations for competitive athletes with cardiovascular abnormalities: task force 3: hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy and other cardiomyopathies, and myocarditis: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association and American College of Cardiology.
Our follow-up evaluation is subject to several limitations. First, and most importantly, the absence of clear clinical practice guidelines for the outpatient follow-up of myocarditis meant that comparing clinical course among patients was challenging, as no standard level of care was provided. Therefore, some data pertinent to understanding potential residual symptoms and disease were unavailable. We found substantial heterogeneity in the initial evaluation and follow-up of patients, particularly in the cardiac diagnostic imaging received. Current guidelines recommend restricting patients with myocarditis (eg, athletes) from competitive sports for 3–6 months,
38
Bonow RO
Nishimura RA
Thompson PD
Udelson JE
Eligibility and disqualification recommendations for competitive athletes with cardiovascular abnormalities: task force 5: valvular heart disease: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association and American College of Cardiology.
although we noted some variability among health-care providers in clearing patients for a return to all physical activity. There are no standard criteria for myocarditis recovery, and we did not identify any clinical feature or diagnostic test results associated with recovery status in the patients we evaluated. Forthcoming expert guidelines regarding the follow-up management and testing of patients with myocarditis could help standardise care in the future.
A second limitation is the passive (or spontaneous) nature of VAERS reporting. Some US cases of myocarditis associated with mRNA COVID-19 vaccination will not have been reported; however, it is unclear how cases reported or not reported initially to VAERS could differ. Selection bias is a possible limitation in any survey activity. Third, although 519 (62%) of the 836 eligible patients with myocarditis who filed a report to VAERS were included in this follow-up evaluation, 275 (33%) declined to participate or were unreachable. Reassuringly, we found no significant differences in the age, sex, race, or census region of respondents compared with non-respondents, although our findings might not be generalisable to all US individuals aged 12–29 years who develop myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination due to the small sample size. Fourth, we relied on health-care provider reports for all diagnostic data results. Unlike prospective studies, we did not have access to central interpretation of tests (eg, electrocardiograms, echocardiograms, and cardiac MRIs). Although this limitation probably introduces some variability into the findings, it also reflects real-world practice and data appeared not to be missing at random. A fifth limitation is the absence of a control group for the analysis of patient symptoms. Control groups are important for contextualising symptoms. For example, in a study of long COVID among children and adolescents (aged
39
Rao S
Lee GM
Razzaghi H
et al.
Clinical features and burden of postacute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection in children and adolescents.
found that 41·9% of patients with a history of COVID-19 reported at least one symptom of post-acute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection, as did 38·2% of a control group without a history of COVID-19. Although no pre-myocarditis measures were available for our group of patients with myocarditis, we found that quality of life measures among those with COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis at follow-up were similar to or better than those of contemporary populations studied before or early in the pandemic.
22
Hay JW
Gong CL
Jiao X
et al.
A US population health survey on the impact of COVID-19 using the EQ-5D-5L.
,
23
Jiang R
Janssen MFB
Pickard AS
US population norms for the EQ-5D-5L and comparison of norms from face-to-face and online samples.
Finally, given limitations on the ability to determine causes of myocarditis other than mRNA vaccination, we included all cases in our analyses.
In summary, after at least 90 days since onset of myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination, 81% of patients were considered recovered by their health-care provider. At the time of follow-up, these patients reported quality of life measures similar to pre-pandemic reports among individuals of similar ages in the USA. 50% of patients reported at least one symptom at follow-up. Among a subset of 151 patients who had follow-up cardiac MRI results, 54% had an abnormal finding. The CDC is conducting additional follow-up on patients who were not considered recovered at least 12 months since symptom onset, to better understand their longer term outcomes.
MEO, KRB, MJC, MMC, JS, JRS, SSM, JMD, CBC, EBW, DKS, and TTS were responsible for project conceptualisation. IK, JW, PM, and JS were responsible for data curation and data analysis. KRB, MMC, MG, KS, BR, ALV, SSM, AA, AR-C, SN, SSM, DKS, TTS, and SVB provided project administration, supervision, and resources. IK, SVB, MEO, DKS, and TTS wrote the original draft. All authors edited the final version. IK and JW had access to all the data and had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication.
