Think the rest of senior year was about to get easy? Think again.
You’ve spent months researching colleges, writing essays, collecting recommendations, and preparing your applications. Now that you’ve submitted your Early Decision or Early Action applications, you can finally relax and enjoy your senior year. Right?
Not so fast. For high school seniors hoping to get into their dream schools, the weeks between November application deadlines and December admissions decisions are not the time to abandon the college application process.
What to know right now: Most universities release early admissions results in mid-December, leaving students just two weeks before early January Regular Decision deadlines. Experts recommend using November to draft supplemental essays, maintain first-semester senior grades, and consider Early Decision II options rather than waiting on a decision.
According to the College Board, most colleges don’t notify early applicants until mid-December. That can leave students who are rejected or deferred with just two weeks to finish their Regular Decision applications before January deadlines.
The Common Application’s recent reporting found that more than 1.5 million students submitted nearly 10.8 million college applications – a 6% increase from the previous year. On average, students applied to 7.06 colleges, compared with 6.79 the year before.
That means even students who believe they have a good chance of getting into their first-choice school need to prepare for other outcomes, according to Christopher Rim, founder and CEO of college admissions consulting company Command Education.
“Writing backup applications doesn’t jinx anything,” Rim said. “We tell students to go into the early round already prepared for a deferral, and to keep working on the rest of their list once they hit submit.”
The key is to remain productive without allowing uncertainty about admissions decisions to overwhelm the final year of high school.
1. Keep your grades up, even after applications are in
Submitting an application doesn’t mean a college stops evaluating academic performance. Many universities require a midyear report containing grades from the first semester or trimester of senior year. Those grades carry substantial weight for applicants who are deferred and reconsidered during Regular Decision.
Princeton University admissions officials require applicants to submit updated grades and emphasize that students must continue performing well throughout senior year. The university also makes clear that admission remains conditional upon the successful completion of high school – reserving the right to withdraw an acceptance if academic performance declines significantly between January and June.
Other selective institutions hold similar expectations. Students who receive early acceptances should resist the temptation to neglect their coursework. Maintaining strong marks is particularly critical for students whose academic records improved during junior year, as consistent senior grades reinforce that upward trajectory.
Students should also continue participating in extracurricular activities rather than abandoning clubs, athletics, research, or community initiatives. Beyond demonstrating authentic commitment to admissions committees, staying involved keeps students mentally and physically grounded during their senior year.
2. Don’t wait for early decisions to work on Regular Decision essays
One of the most common pitfalls for early applicants is becoming so invested in their top-choice school that they delay preparing backup applications.
Rim notes that students sometimes worry that working on regular applications signals a lack of confidence in their early choice. The flaw in that logic becomes painfully clear if a deferral or rejection arrives in December. Students who could have spent November preparing their remaining applications are suddenly faced with completing several complex supplements, tracking down missing transcripts, and meeting deadlines during the holiday break.
Key regular decision deadlines arrive quickly at the start of the year:
Fortunately, applicants are rarely starting from scratch. “The student isn’t starting from scratch,” Rim explained. “The personal statement, the Activities List, and the core narrative are already crafted.” Rather than developing entirely new themes, students can repurpose their core narrative to address specific institutional prompts.
However, students should avoid recycling generic essays. Admissions committees easily distinguish between an applicant who copied a generic template and one who understands specific academic programs, labs and faculty.
“The students who write the most convincing ‘Why Us’ essays have attended information sessions, taken virtual tours, and talked with current students or faculty,” Rim said. “The key lies in going back to their notes about each school (particularly if they visited the campus) so that they can connect their application narrative to their specific interest in the institution.”
3. Consider whether Early Decision II makes strategic sense
Students who are not admitted during the initial early round may have another opportunity to target a preferred school through Early Decision II (ED II).
Like Early Decision I, ED II is a binding commitment: students admitted under ED II pledge to attend that institution. The primary distinction is the schedule. While ED I applications are typically submitted in November with decisions delivered in December, ED II applications are generally due in January with decisions announced in February.
For instance, Vanderbilt University offers an ED II option with a January deadline and decisions delivered in mid-February.
ED II serves as an effective strategy for students with a definitive second-choice institution who are willing to commit if admitted. However, students who were deferred or rejected in ED I must ensure they are formally released from their initial binding agreement before signing another.
4. Use campus visits and information sessions strategically
The November lull offers a practical window to research colleges remaining on a student’s list through campus visits, virtual webinars, and informational sessions.
These touchpoints can also help with institutions that track “demonstrated interest,” a metric assessing how proactively a student has engaged with the school.
Policies vary widely by university:
- Tufts University explicitly encourages prospective applicants to engage through campus visits, information sessions, and regional events.
- Brown University and Vanderbilt University, by contrast, explicitly state that visiting campus or contacting admissions representatives provides no advantage in admissions decisions.
Applicants should verify whether each school on their list tracks demonstrated interest before prioritizing outreach.
5. Keep perspective and avoid reactive overhauls
The weeks between submitting applications and opening decision portals are emotionally taxing. Rim advises families to mentally prepare for a deferral without viewing a negative decision as an indictment of the student’s intellect or potential.
“First, be careful about blaming the essay,” Rim said. “Deferrals often come from institutional priorities or applicant pool makeup and have little or nothing to do with the writing itself.”
Selective colleges balance dozens of institutional variables, meaning a qualified candidate can be rejected simply due to institutional limits. Rim strongly cautions against reacting to a deferral by abruptly rewriting an entire application strategy: “Reactive strategies rarely succeed, so the worst thing a student can do after a deferral is tear everything up and start over.”
Instead, students should maintain steady progress on regular decision deadlines while protecting time for personal interests.
Karen Richardson, dean of admission at Princeton, shared similar encouragement in a university admissions essay to applicants, advising seniors to enjoy their final high school year, sustain their academic discipline, and keep participating in the activities they care about.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the difference between being deferred and being rejected?
Being deferred means an admissions committee has moved an Early Action or Early Decision application into the Regular Decision pool for further evaluation alongside the general applicant pool. A rejection is a final decision for that application cycle.
Can a college rescind an acceptance after early admission?
Yes. Nearly all college acceptance letters state that admission is conditional. Substantial drops in second-semester senior grades, disciplinary infractions, or failure to graduate will result in an acceptance being rescinded.
When do Early Decision decisions come out?
Most universities release Early Action and Early Decision I notifications between December 10 and December 20. Early Decision II decisions are generally announced in February.
This article was written by Brooklyn-based financial journalist and Commerce Editor for the New York Post Will Kenton. Specializing in investing, personal finance and retirement planning, Will’s expertise is rooted in behavioral economics — a field he explored as associate editor of the New School Economics Review. Will aims to help readers navigate the “predictable irrationality” that influences financial decisions, providing practical real-world solutions to student loan debt, investments, mortgages and more. Before joining The Post in 2026, Will covered the intersection of money, economics and culture for Investopedia, AP News, Business Insider and TIME Stamped.
This article was written by Brooklyn-based financial journalist and Commerce Editor for the New York Post Will Kenton. Specializing in investing, personal finance and retirement planning, Will’s expertise is rooted in behavioral economics — a field he explored as associate editor of the New School Economics Review. Will aims to help readers navigate the “predictable irrationality” that influences financial decisions, providing practical real-world solutions to student loan debt, investments, mortgages and more. Before joining The Post in 2026, Will covered the intersection of money, economics and culture for Investopedia, AP News, Business Insider and TIME Stamped.
Source link
#submitted #early #college #applications #Heres